Why SMBs are ditching ADP

ADP remains the largest payroll provider by market share due to its large, enterprise customer base and global payroll capabilities. Now, with frequent mass layoffs impacting larger organizations, the vendor must work to avoid increasing rates of SMB customer churn to maintain its positioning. Nucleus interviewed former ADP customers, who cited poor support, complex functionality, and high costs as primary drivers behind their decision to switch to another vendor. For example, one organization saved $40,000 a year upon implementing a solution from a close competitor. As other SMB-focused HCM and payroll providers continue to develop their platforms with higher usability and a lower price point, ADP must invest heavily in these areas to prevent erosion of its customer base.

  • Have a specific question? Query our research catalogue with the Nucleus AI Tool.
  • Learn more about Nucleus Research’s ROI case study approach here.
  • Gain the knowledge you need to effectively develop and deliver a financial business case at ROIUniversity.com.

RELATED RESEARCH

    Anatomy of a decision: Domo

    Have a specific question? Query our research catalogue with the Nucleus AI Tool. Nucleus interviewed Domo customers to understand the primary drivers behind the selection of…

    CPQ Technology Value Matrix 2025

    Have a specific question? Query our research catalogue with the Nucleus AI Tool. The Configure, Price, Quote (CPQ) market in 2025 is increasingly defined by the…

    WMS Technology Value Matrix 2025

    In 2025, warehouse management technology is advancing from process execution to intelligent orchestration as organizations navigate rising costs, labor shortages, and global trade instability. Nucleus…

    ROI case study: Oracle at logistics services

    Have a specific question? Query our research catalogue with the Nucleus AI Tool. A logistics services provider achieved a 396 percent ROI and a 3.1-month payback…

    Fusion’s financial impact: unifying ERP, EPM, and SCM

    Have a specific question? Query our research catalogue with the Nucleus AI Tool. Enterprises deploying Oracle Fusion Applications including ERP, EPM, and SCM reported improvements by…

    Accelerating time to value through proven implementation practices

    Have a specific question? Query our research catalogue with the Nucleus AI Tool. Through end-user conversations across hundreds of ERP, SCM, CPM, HCM, Analytics, and CRM…